No, this trade is not fair.
| Player | Rating | Health | Own % | Start % | Role | 2025 Performance | News/Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Shohei Ohtani | 34.38 | Healthy (DH only) | 100 | ~80–100 | Top-3 overall hitter | .278/.385/.548, 7 HR, 32 R, 9 SB | Elite anchor, no injury concerns, not pitching in 2025 |
| Austin Riley | 18.73 | Healthy | 100 | ~84–97 | Top-7 3B | .280/.323/.464, 6 HR, 20 RBI | Very good but not league-winning |
| Gerrit Cole | 0.00 | Out for season | 17 | 3 | IR/Bench | N/A | Tommy John, no 2025 value |
This trade is extremely lopsided in favor of the team acquiring Shohei Ohtani and should not be approved. Cole’s lack of value makes this a straight Riley-for-Ohtani swap, which is nowhere close to fair value. Ohtani is a league-winning, irreplaceable fantasy asset, while Riley is a strong but much less impactful hitter and Cole is a non-factor for 2025.
Recommendation: Reject or renegotiate. Consider adding a second elite player or a healthy, high-end starter on the Riley side to approach fairness. As it stands, this trade cannot be approved.
TIP A fair trade is ideal with a rating of 80% or more.
Ratings from all players involved in this trade over the course of the season.
Similar to above except its all player ratings from each side of the trade.
Purchase a membership to see how this trade impacts both sides of the trade.
See exactly which categories are affected, how positional rankings change, and which team improves the most.
Plus, we can even generate trades for you that may be better for you.
Use promo code 'ready' for 10% OFF.
| Player | RATING |
|---|---|
| Yordan Alvarez HOU DH | 26.99 |
| Ben Rice NYY 1B | 26.95 |
| Pete Crow-Armstrong CHC CF | 26.05 |
| Elly De La Cruz CIN SS | 22.76 |
| Drew Rasmussen TB SP | 22.07 |
| Cade Smith CLE RP | 21.11 |
| Jacob Misiorowski MIL SP | 20.58 |
| Cam Schlittler NYY SP | 20.25 |
| Pete Alonso BAL 1B | 20.04 |
| Randy Arozarena LF | 19.71 |
| Shohei Ohtani LAD DH | 19.65 |
| Miguel Vargas CHW 3B | 19.23 |
| Gavin Williams CLE SP | 18.94 |
| Brice Turang MIL 2B | 18.42 |
| Junior Caminero TB 3B | 18.18 |
By Sheldon Moody NHL
By Sheldon Moody NHL
By Morgan Rode NFL
By Morgan Rode NFL
By Morgan Rode NBA
By Daniel Hepner NFL
| Louis Varland TOR RP | +5.3 |
| Julio Rodriguez SEA CF | +5.3 |
| Aaron Judge NYY RF | +5.0 |
| Liam Hicks TB C | +5.0 |
| Jake Bauers BOS 1B | +5.0 |
| Freddy Peralta SP | +5.0 |
| Ian Happ LF | +4.7 |
| Teoscar Hernandez LAD LF | +4.4 |
| Carson Benge NYM RF | +4.1 |
| MacKenzie Gore TEX SP | +4.1 |
| Noah Cameron KC SP | +3.8 |
| Ernie Clement TOR 2B | +3.8 |
| Colson Montgomery CHW SS | +3.8 |
| TJ Rumfield COL 1B | +3.8 |
| Steven Okert RP | +3.8 |
| Chase Burns CIN SP | -5.6 |
| Royce Lewis LAD 1B | -5.0 |
| Mickey Gasper BOS C | -4.7 |
| Lucas Erceg KC RP | -4.7 |
| Christian Encarnacion-Strand BAL 3B | -4.7 |
| Joe Musgrove SD SP | -4.7 |
| Ethan Salas SD C | -4.7 |
| Paul Sewald RP | -4.7 |
| Joshua Baez STL LF | -4.7 |
| Ryan Helsley BAL RP | -4.7 |
| lazaro montes SEA RF | -4.7 |
| Matt McLain CIN 2B | -4.4 |
| Luis Robert Jr. CF | -4.4 |
| Kodai Senga NYM SP | -4.4 |
| Brady Singer SP | -4.4 |
Packers’ Josh Jacobs Unlikely to Play Wednesday After Finger Surgery
@mattschneidman
Sean Rhyan, Zaire Franklin Set to Return to Practice for First Time Since Week 7
@mattschneidman
Rangers’ Bjorkstrand, Smits Out 2–3 Months; Glendening Headed to Waivers
@drosennhl
Alperen ĹžengĂĽn Ditches Protective Glasses After One Quarter
@WillGuillory
Latest On Freddy Peralta
MLBTradeRumors
James Harden Makes NBA History With 50-Point Games Against 18 Teams
@cavs
Packers’ Josh Jacobs Unlikely to Play Wednesday After Finger Surgery
@mattschneidman
Sean Rhyan, Zaire Franklin Set to Return to Practice for First Time Since Week 7
@mattschneidman
Carnell Tate Likely to Play in Week 11 Despite Shoulder Injury
@UnderdogNFL
Report: Puka Nacua’s Future With Rams Uncertain
@rotoworld_fb
Saquon Barkley Healthier After Bye Week, but Still Managing Injuries
@ZBerm
Greg Cosell Breaks Down Broncos’ Route Concepts for Bo Nix vs. Raiders
@NFLMatchup
Latest On Freddy Peralta
MLBTradeRumors
Mets Reportedly Make Record-Breaking Skubal Offer, Sign Hernandez and Tender Vientos Contract
@nypostsports
Tigers Extend Troy Melton, Potentially Through 2033, Signaling No Long-Term Arm Concerns
@Lynn_Henning
FanGraphs Weekly Mailbag: November 21, 2026
fangraphs.com
River Ryan, 2027 Fantasy Outlook
razzball.com
MLB Offseason Buzz: White Sox Trade, Peralta’s Market and Arenado’s Arizona Fit
@Ken_Rosenthal
Alperen ĹžengĂĽn Ditches Protective Glasses After One Quarter
@WillGuillory
James Harden Makes NBA History With 50-Point Games Against 18 Teams
@cavs
OG Anunoby Downgraded to Doubtful, Karl-Anthony Towns Questionable Due to Illness
@JLEdwardsIII
Jonathan Kuminga Fuels Minnesota’s No. 1 Defense With Career-Best Stats
@WolvesRadio
James Harden Evades Water Shower After Epic Performance
@NBA
OG Anunoby Doubtful With Calf Tightness; Karl-Anthony Towns Questionable With Illness
@FredKatz
Rangers’ Bjorkstrand, Smits Out 2–3 Months; Glendening Headed to Waivers
@drosennhl
Rangers Update: Smits and Bjorkstrand Out 2–3 Months; Glendening Set for Waivers, Dorofeyev Skates
@StapeNHL
Stolarz Starts Again for Toronto; Mermis Replaces Ekman-Larsson, Talbot Set for Columbus Game
@FriedgeHNIC
Canucks Place Brendan Gallagher on Injured Reserve, Retroactive to Nov. 19
@Canucks
Islanders’ Ryan Pulock Out Tonight With Upper-Body Injury
@NYIslanders
Scott Morrow Could Stay in Lineup, With Robertson Potentially Out
@Peter_Baugh