Fantasy Hockey Rookie Roundup: McKenna, Other Top Prospects Struggling to Make Impact
Shelmo discusses four highly-touted rookies who have received significant opportunities this season but are struggling to consistently translate their talent into NHL production.
Hey folks. We knew this year's rookie class had plenty of high-end talent, but sometimes the transition to the NHL is a lot harder than expected. Several of the league's most exciting young players have been given significant opportunities early in their careers, but not all of them have been able to capitalize.
We looked at five rookies before the season started with some predictions, and today we're going to cover four of them and see how they are doing. Spoiler alert: not good.
While fantasy managers are still excited about the long-term potential of these players, their current production, deployment, and overall game have left plenty to be desired. Some are being asked to do too much, while others are struggling to find consistency in roles that should be providing opportunities to succeed.
Let's dive in and take a closer look at these rookies who have been underwhelming so far this season.
Connect your league to uncover strengths & weaknesses, waiver assistance, trade scenarios, and get instant start/sit clarity.
Want to take your fantasy hockey analysis further? EDGE+ members can now chat with our AI Expert, ask follow-up questions, and dive deeper into player breakdowns with longer conversations.
Gavin McKenna - Toronto Maple Leafs
McKenna has been given every opportunity to succeed in Toronto, playing a top-six role and receiving powerplay opportunities alongside some of the best offensive players in the league. However, the transition to the NHL has been anything but smooth, and while the talent is obviously there, he has shown he still has a lot to learn as a No. 1 pick.
The biggest concern is his defensive game, which has been a complete trainwreck at times. McKenna has single-handedly cost the Maple Leafs several games with his defensive mistakes, and there are times when he looks like he is cheating the game by focusing too much on offense instead of making the responsible play.
At the start of the season, McKenna wasn't even going to practice skates with the team. What kind of rookie thinks he needs to stay fresh, or is good enough not to practice with the team? Optional or not, he should be there.
The offensive production hasn't been consistent enough to make up for those shortcomings, either. He has struggled to find his footing at times, and despite receiving plenty of opportunities in the top six and on the powerplay, he hasn't been able to consistently translate those opportunities into production.
Fantasy Outlook: McKenna is still worth holding onto in most leagues, especially dynasty formats, because the offensive talent is undeniable. However, redraft managers need to temper their expectations, as his inconsistent production and defensive struggles could lead to more inconsistent deployment moving forward.
Porter Martone - Philadelphia Flyers
Martone has been doing reasonably well this season, playing on the third line alongside Matvei Michkov while also receiving opportunities on the top powerplay unit. He currently has nine points, with five of those coming on the man advantage, which is encouraging but still leaves plenty of room for improvement at even strength.
The biggest issue is that Martone hasn't been able to consistently generate offence despite receiving some pretty good opportunities. He has the size, skill, and physicality to become a very good NHL forward, but his defensive game remains a work in progress, and he is still learning how to handle the pace and responsibilities of the NHL.
Fantasy Outlook: Martone remains an intriguing hold, especially in dynasty leagues, and his powerplay deployment gives him some fantasy value in deeper formats. I would like to see him become more productive at even strength before considering him a reliable fantasy contributor, but there is plenty of upside here if Philadelphia eventually gives him a bigger role.
Anton Frondell - Chicago Blackhawks
Frondell is currently centering the top line with Connor Bedard out of the lineup, but I don't think he is ready for that kind of responsibility. Chicago doesn't have enough depth to adequately replace Bedard, and Frondell has been asked to take on too much for a young player who is still learning how to play at the NHL level.
His production has been respectable, but it hasn't been anywhere near what you would expect from a top-line player, and his ice time has been extremely inconsistent. Some nights he is playing close to 18 minutes, while other nights he barely reaches 10, which makes it difficult to establish any sort of rhythm or confidence.
I don't think this is necessarily a reflection of Frondell's talent, but rather a lack of depth in Chicago that is forcing him into a role he isn't ready for. He has struggled defensively at times, and his minus rating is another indication that he still has plenty of work to do away from the puck.
Fantasy Outlook: Frondell is still a player I would hold in dynasty leagues because the long-term potential is there, but I think redraft managers need to be patient. Once Bedard returns, Frondell should be able to settle into a more appropriate role, and I think that could actually help his overall production and development.
Ivar Stenberg - San Jose Sharks
Stenberg has been the most productive rookie of this group, with seven goals and 14 points, while playing alongside Macklin Celebrini on the top line. He has also been receiving significant powerplay opportunities, and while he has been able to take advantage of some of those chances, I think he is still being asked to do too much too soon.
The biggest concern for me is his defensive reliability, as he has struggled in his own end and is another rookie with a minus rating. The offensive talent is obvious, but he still needs to become more consistent defensively and learn how to handle the responsibilities that come with playing alongside a franchise player.
Fantasy Outlook: Stenberg is the most intriguing fantasy option of this group right now because he has actually been producing, and playing alongside Celebrini should continue to provide plenty of offensive opportunities. I would be holding him in most leagues, but managers need to remember that he is still a rookie who is learning how to play the NHL game, and his production could fluctuate as the Sharks continue to develop their young core.