Giants Dynasty Fantasy Football Overview: Who could Join Malik Nabers as an Elite Asset?

It's time to go over another dynasty overview for an NFL team. We'll look at the New York Giants here.

We already looked at the Eagles, Chiefs, Lions, Bills, Ravens, Vikings, Commanders, Chargers, Packers, Texans, Rams, Steelers, Buccaneers, Broncos, Bears, Colts, Cowboys, Jaguars, Dolphins, Seahawks and Patriots. I plan to cover every NFL team, so keep checking back for more!

Wish a real fantasy expert could break down your team, not just spit out generic advice? Now you can - get a personalized Team Breakdown, tailored for your exact league.

Quarterbacks

Russell Wilson looks like he'll be the starting quarterback for the Giants this season. Rookie Jaxson Dart is viewed as a potential franchise starter, while Jameis Winston and Tommy DeVito are on the roster for now as well.

None of those guys made my top-10 dynasty list for QBs, and Dart is the only one with a chance to get there someday.

Wilson is 36 years old, so his dynasty value is fading out. He showed he could still play a bit last year, and could be an underrated fantasy asset in 2025.

He's only worth rostering on a contending dynasty team though. Otherwise, I'd sell him for some future assets.

Winston is 31 years old, and is a backup at this point of his career. He can fill in here and there, but there's likely to not be any times where he's a sought-after fantasy asset ever again.

DeVito has got a little NFL experience over his two years in the league. He looks like another backup, but might get a change of scenery with all the other QBs the Giants have on the roster.

Dart was the No. 25 overall pick, so New York is hoping he becomes a starting QB in time. Getting to learn from the quarterbacks on the roster for a season would be the best thing for the 22-year-old QB, but I'm sure the Giants will throw him into the fire at some point.

As long as the Giants don't ruin him right away, I could see Dart becoming a decent fantasy QB down the road. He might be behind the eight ball because of where he landed, but at some point, a QB prospect has to hit, and maybe it will be Dart. He should be rostered in most dynasty setups, but I wouldn't expect a ton out of him in 2025.

Running Backs

Tyrone Tracy Jr. is the team's starting running back for now. Devin Singletary and rookie Cam Skattebo are a couple secondary options worth discussing as well. Eric Gray is also on the roster, but might not be for long.

None of those backs are on my top-10 dynasty list, and while a couple could get there someday, they have uphill climbs to reach that lofty list.

I really liked what Tracy did in his rookie season, when he combined for 1,123 yards and six touchdowns across 17 games. He's 25 years old already though, and now has backfield competition, so he's possibly already peaked, which seems crazy to say.

I'd consider selling him high if I rostered him in a dynasty league. I think he's already a player to only roster on a contending team, because I think he'll eventually lose the top role in New York, maybe even as soon as this season.

Singletary is the veteran in the RB room. The 27-year-old (nearly 28) had 556 yards and four touchdowns across 15 games last season, which was a far cry from the three straight 1,000-plus yard seasons he had. 

He's fading as a dynasty asset, so I'd sell him if I wasn't contending (and maybe even if I was, as I could see Singletary getting cut).

Skattebo is a popular dynasty name as the Giants are looking for long-term playmakers. The 23-year-old was taken in the fourth round of the 2025 NFL Draft.

Skattebo has top-10 dynasty potential, but will likely need to excel as a rookie to get there seeing he's already 23. I like the idea of rostering Skattebo in almost every dynasty league, as he's both an asset who could help this season, but has better long-term potential.

Gray is on the PUP list to kick off his third NFL season. The 26-year-old has just 183 yards and no scores over his first 30 games after being a fifth-round pick in 2023. He hasn't developed into the player the Giants were hoping for, and he could be let go, especially because they have three other backs they could trust already. His dynasty value has dried up, and he's only worth rostering in the deepest dynasty leagues out there.

Wide Receivers

Malik Nabers is the star player for the Giants' offense. Darius Slayton and Wan'Dale Robinson are the other projected starting wideouts, while Jalin Hyatt and Ihmir Smith-Marsette are next up on the depth chart. Beaux Collins, Zach Pascal and Lil'Jordan Humphrey are also worth discussing on a team lacking a ton of wideout depth.

Nabers is my No. 3 dynasty wideout, and he could still move up that list as he's only 22 years old. He had 1,206 total yards and seven touchdowns across a 15-game rookie season.

Nabers has the chance to shine for several more years. He's already emerged as a top-end fantasy option, and if the Giants figure out their long-term quarterback, Nabers could really erupt.

Nabers is a dynasty player to build around.

Slayton is 28 years old and coming off a 590-yard and two-touchdown season last year. He played in 16 games.

He has some dynasty value left, but is more a depth option than anything. Roster him on contending teams, or look to move him for some future assets.

Robinson is 24 years old and has improved a bit across his first three seasons. He had 717 yards and three scores last year across 17 games.

He has the chance to keep improving and of becoming a good No. 2 option after Nabers. Robinson isn't likely to ever turn into a top-end fantasy talent, but he's worth rostering in dynasty leagues, regardless of the status of your team.

Smith-Marsette is 25 years old, but already on his sixth team as he enters his fifth NFL season. He has just 255 yards and three scores over 48 total games, so his dynasty value is very low at this point.

Hyatt is 23 years old, but took a step backward in 2024. He needs to show something this season in order to remain even a little relevant in the deepest of dynasty leagues.

Pascal is 30 years old, but hasn't had over 150 yards since 2021. He's a veteran option for a wideout room lacking proven guys, so he might make the team. He won't be very involved most likely, and doesn't have much dynasty value either.

Humphrey has a little more dynasty value as a 27-year-old, but on his fourth team and entering his seventh-season, he's not a big asset. He could make some noise if there's some injuries ahead of him, but he's only worth stashing on your bench in really deep dynasty setups.

Collins was an undrafted rookie this offseason. I only mention him because he's listed as the backup to Nabers on OurLads, and is ahead of guys like Pascal and Humphrey. Maybe the 22-year-old could surprise in time, but it's more likely the Giants replace him with a pick or free agent signing in time.

Tight Ends

Theo Johnson is the projected starting tight end, with Daniel Bellinger and Chris Manhertz as veteran backups. Rookie Thomas Fidone II and Greg Dulcich are further down the depth chart.

None of those guys are on my top-10 dynasty TE list, and only Johnson has an outside chance of getting there probably.

Johnson is 24 years old and had 331 yards and a score across 12 games as a rookie. He could be pretty heavily involved going into year two with a lack of proven wideouts after the starters.

Johnson is worth stashing on some deeper dynasty rosters yet. I don't see him becoming a top-end option ever, but he could be a decent backup for several years maybe.

Bellinger is 24, but has just 650 yards and three scores (all as a rookie) over his first three NFL seasons. He looks like a career backup at TE, and doesn't have much dynasty value.

Manhertz is 33 years old and has accumulated just 301 yards and three scores over his first nine years in the league. He's off the fantasy radar, even if he were to play a bunch or start.

Dulcich is 25 years old and looking to start making a difference after fizzling out in Denver. He has 464 yards and two scores over 21 games in three years. There's a touch of dynasty value left, but it's just about gone.

Fidone has an uphill climb to relevance after being a seventh-round pick. He didn't accomplish much in college either, so him breaking out in the NFL would be a shock to many. Only roster him in the deepest of dynasty leagues as a longshot lottery ticket.