MLB

Fantasy Baseball Waiver Wire: Best Pitching Adds for Thursday

Looking for pitching help? Here are the top fantasy baseball waiver wire arms to target Thursday, from immediate streamers to stash-worthy upside plays.

Morgan Rode May 21st 9:38 AM EDT.

May 16, 2026; Denver, Colorado, USA; Arizona Diamondbacks pitcher Eduardo Rodriguez (57) pitches in the first inning against the Colorado Rockies at Coors Field. Credit: Christopher Hanewinckel-Imagn Images
May 16, 2026; Denver, Colorado, USA; Arizona Diamondbacks pitcher Eduardo Rodriguez (57) pitches in the first inning against the Colorado Rockies at Coors Field. Credit: Christopher Hanewinckel-Imagn Images

Let's open Thursday by checking out some fantasy baseball waiver wire options, looking at pitchers first.

Check back later for an article on waiver wire hitters.

Fantasy baseball waiver wire options can be found all season on FantasySP!

Eduardo Rodriguez - Arizona Diamondbacks

Rodriguez is on the rise as he prepares to make a start on Thursday. He is up 4.34% so far and sits at 67.34% overall now.

Rodriguez will get a matchup against the Rockies today, which is a fantastic matchup. Even better, the game is in Arizona and not Colorado.

Fantasy Assistant
Put Your Lineup Under the Microscope

Connect your league to uncover strengths & weaknesses, waiver assistance, trade scenarios, and get instant start/sit clarity.

He's made nine starts this season, and he sits with a 4-1 record and 2.53 earned run average so far. He has allowed 16 runs (15 earned) on 45 hits and 22 walks, while striking out 39 over 53 1/3 innings. 

Rodriguez faced Colorado last week, allowing three runs on nine hits and no walks, while striking out six over 5 1/3 innings. That game was in Colorado, so I expect better out of Rodriguez this time around.

I like Rodriguez in all deeper leagues for sure, and he's a pretty solid standard league streaming option as well. Consider Rodriguez in all leagues in this stellar matchup today.

Cade Cavalli - Washington Nationals

Cavalli has been picked up in 3.21% of leagues, which brings his overall mark to 28.96%.

He'll be starting against the Mets on Thursday afternoon. That's a pretty favorable matchup on paper.

Cavalli has been a so-so fantasy asset this season over 10 starts. He's 2-2 with a 4.05 ERA over 46 2/3 innings. Cavalli has allowed 28 runs (21 earned) on 54 hits and 18 walks, while striking out 52 batters.

He's faced the Mets already, tossing six innings against them on April 29. Cavalli got a win after allowing two runs on eight hits and two walks, while striking out 10.

I expect solid results from Cavalli this time around. He's a good deep-league streaming asset, and could also be considered in some standard leagues, although he's more of a lottery ticket because of his ERA and prior results this season.

Casey Mize - Detroit Tigers

Mize has been added in 2.42% of leagues and sits at 75.33% overall now.

He will be starting against the Guardians on Thursday afternoon. That's a pretty solid matchup on paper, but Mize is more rising because of what he's done this season so far.

Across seven starts, he's just 2-2, but he has a 2.43 ERA over 37 innings pitched. Mize has allowed 10 runs on 28 hits and 11 walks, while striking out 39 batters.

This will be his first start against Cleveland in 2026. Mize has pitched well enough to try in all deeper leagues, and a good amount of standard leagues too. Give him consideration at least.

Grant Taylor - Chicago White Sox

Taylor has been added in 4.13% of leagues and is rostered in 17.51% overall.

Taylor is a reliever for Chicago, and he earned his first save a couple days ago. He has a 1-0 record, the save, a blown save and two holds so far.

He has pitched in 19 games, covering 25 1/3 innings. Taylor has allowed eight runs (five earned) on 21 hits and eight walks, while striking out 38 batters.

Taylor was a decent fantasy asset even before earning a save. The save came after Seranthony Dominguez blew a save a couple days prior, so there's a chance that Taylor eventually overtakes Dominguez.

For now, Taylor can be added in some deeper fantasy leagues. Keep tabs on him and be ready to add him if he's earning the save chances in Chicago. The White Sox are winning enough for now to at least own a go-to closer in deeper fantasy leagues.

Trevor McDonald - San Francisco Giants

McDonald sits at 34% rostered right now. He's a starting pitcher, but not pitching on Thursday.

He will be starting on Friday, and doing so against the White Sox, who are a good matchup. McDonald is being added a day early, and rightfully so with how he's looked so far this season.

McDonald has made three starts, and is 2-0 with a 2.37 ERA so far. He's pitched 19 innings, allowing just five runs on 16 hits and three walks. McDonald has struck out 17 batters so far.

McDonald will be a very good deep-league streaming asset for Friday, and with how he's pitched, I wouldn't mind trying him in standard leagues too. Beat the rush to grab him on Friday and just stash him on Thursday, which is a lighter day of MLB action anyways.

#waivers #closers

More From FantasySP

Latest from FSP

Waiver Trends

More Trends
Max Meyer MIA SP +15.0
Franklin Arias +11.8
Braxton Ashcraft PIT SP +11.5
Chase DeLauter CLE RF +10.0
Willson Contreras BOS 1B +8.8
Maikel Garcia KC 3B +8.8
Teoscar Hernandez LAD LF +8.2
Jake Bennett BOS SP +7.5
Riley O'Brien STL RP +7.5
Tyler Soderstrom ATH LF +7.5
Will Smith LAD C +7.5
Casey Mize SP +7.5
Angel Martinez CLE LF +7.5
Jared Jones PIT SP +7.4
Dansby Swanson CHC SS +7.1
Ildemaro Vargas 1B -6.5
Jackson Holliday BAL 2B -6.3
Brandon Nimmo TEX RF -6.3
Vinnie Pasquantino KC 1B -5.6
Gunnar Henderson BAL SS -5.0
Chase Burns CIN SP -5.0
Drew Anderson DET RP -5.0
Cade Horton CHC SP -4.5
Emerson Hancock SEA SP -4.4
David Hamilton MIL 3B -4.1
Salvador Perez KC DH -3.9
Janson Junk MIA SP -3.9
Jacob Lopez ATH SP -3.8
Andrew Abbott CIN SP -3.8
Tommy Edman LAD 2B -3.8

Player News