Dominate Fantasy - Sync your team
MLB
SD
PHI
o8.5
-1.5
1:05PM • PREVIEW NBC
BAL
BOS
o10.5
+1.5
1:35PM • PREVIEW NESN
CLE
NYY
o9
-1.5
1:35PM • PREVIEW YES
SF
MIL
o9
-1.5
2:10PM • PREVIEW BREW
TOR
ATL
o7.5
-1.5
7:15PM • PREVIEW BVSN
KC
MIN
o9
+1.5
7:40PM • PREVIEW MNNT
ATH
CHC
o10
-1.5
8:05PM • PREVIEW NBC
PIT
HOU
o8.5
+1.5
8:10PM • PREVIEW SN LA
LAD
ARI
o9
+1.5
9:40PM • PREVIEW SN LA

Jake McCarthy or Colson Montgomery

Who Should I Start? - Week 12 • Start New
Jake McCarthy

Jake McCarthy

CFColorado Rockies COL
Colson Montgomery

Colson Montgomery

SSChicago White Sox CHW
OR
🔓 EXPERT ANALYSIS

Owners starting McCarthy over Montgomery

 
 
 
 
START BOTH START BENCH BOTH BN

Includes Detailed Projections

Outlook Jake McCarthy

Jake McCarthy Shines as the Rockies' Primary Outfielder Amid Injuries

Jake McCarthy has been on a tear, batting .298 with three home runs and four steals over his last 30 days to help provide a spark for the fifth-place Rockies (22-38). With Brenton Doyle and Mickey Moniak both sidelined on the injured list, McCarthy has locked down everyday duties as Colorado's primary center fielder. His recent hot streak includes a stellar .304 average over the last seven days, cementing his near-term fantasy appeal.

While his rest-of-season projection sits at a more modest .252 average with 14 steals, McCarthy's current .275 mark on the year aligns closer to his highly successful 2024 campaign. His high-end speed makes the stolen-base output entirely sustainable, though his power will likely regress back toward our projected six home runs. He remains a valuable speed asset who is capitalizing perfectly on his expanded playing time.

The Rockies play six games this week, starting with a road series against the Angels before returning home to face the Brewers. Matchups are mixed, with a highly favorable draw against Grayson Rodriguez (7.53 ERA) but incredibly tough tests against Jacob Misiorowski (1.65 ERA) and Kyle Harrison (1.57 ERA) later in the week. Given his everyday volume and category-winning speed, McCarthy is a solid option to slide into your active lineup. Verdict: Start.

Updated 3 days ago

Latest News Jake McCarthy
Loading...
🔓 EXPERT ANALYSIS

Owners starting Montgomery over McCarthy

 
 
 
 
START BOTH START BENCH BOTH BN

Includes Detailed Projections

Outlook Colson Montgomery

Colson Montgomery’s Power Surge Makes Him a Locked-In Play This Week

Colson Montgomery is swinging a red-hot bat, slugging .692 with a .346 batting average and two home runs over his last seven games. He continues to secure his role as Chicago's everyday starting shortstop, which is crucial now that star teammate Munetaka Murakami is sidelined on the injured list. His efforts have kept the second-place White Sox (32-27) rolling.

Montgomery's recent tear provides a welcome boost after a colder stretch that saw him hit just .224 over the last fortnight. This volatility is typical for a young shortstop, but his 15 home runs on the season showcase real, sustainable power. Our models project him to reach 19 home runs with a .226 rest-of-season average, meaning you should expect solid pop with a slightly draining batting average.

The White Sox embark on a six-game road trip, starting with three in Minnesota and three in Philadelphia. While the week kicks off tough against Joe Ryan (2.94 ERA), Montgomery gets highly favorable matchups later against Connor Prielipp (5.13 ERA), Andrew Painter (5.74 ERA), and Aaron Nola (5.72 ERA). With plenty of vulnerable pitching on deck, he is a must-play. Weekly Verdict: Start.

Updated 3 days ago

Latest News Colson Montgomery
Loading...
Performance Jake McCarthy
Fantasy Chart Loading...

AVG HR RBI R OBP SLG SB GP
.360277.4290.72016
Season stats based on the past 7 days

AVG HR RBI R OBP SLG SB GP
.264289.3040.434113
Season stats based on the past 14 days
Performance Colson Montgomery
Fantasy Chart Loading...

AVG HR RBI R OBP SLG SB GP
.192233.2500.46207
Season stats based on the past 7 days

AVG HR RBI R OBP SLG SB GP
.220255.2910.400013
Season stats based on the past 14 days
Next Up Own/Start Comparison
OWN/START Jake McCarthy
OWN
29%
+12.63 compared to last week
START
24%
+14.51 compared to last week
OWN/START Colson Montgomery
OWN
83%
+1.6 compared to last week
START
67%
-7.08 compared to last week
Next Up Consensus Rankings
Expert Consensus Jake McCarthy
82nd
Average Ranking of Fantasy Experts
Expert Consensus Colson Montgomery
16th
Average Ranking of Fantasy Experts
Next Up Player Breakdowns
Breakdown Jake McCarthy

    Overview

  • He is eligible to play multiple positions including: CF LF RF . However, he plays CF most often.
  • Experts rank this player at 83rd among OF's. Based on his stats from the past 60 days, he is currently ranked 35th.
  • The current leader among OF's is James Wood
  • You have to be impressed by how much better he is performing. Can he keep this up or is it a fluke?
  • Trending Batting Stats

  • Top 75 in BABIP (Batting Average on Balls In Play) with 0.352 and is currently ranked 64th
  • Top 35 in batting average with 0.306 and is currently ranked 31st
  • Not overly impressive with on base percentage currently ranked 106th with 0.351
  • Top 50 in slugging percentage and is currently ranked 45th with 0.507
  • Top 75 in on base plus slugging and is currently ranked 52nd with 0.859
  • Not very impressive in steals and is currently ranked 114th with 6
  • Not too impressive and is currently ranked 180th in RBI with 25
  • Not too impressive and is currently ranked 247th in runs scored with 20
  • His average points in the past two weeks have remained fairly consistant and rose slightly by 0.6 PPG.
  • At this point in the season his numbers compared to last years: AVG: +0.204, OBP: +0.154, HRs: +4, RBI: +23, Runs: +19, Wlks: +7, Stls: +9,
Breakdown Colson Montgomery

    Overview

  • He is eligible to play multiple positions including: SS 3B . However, he plays SS most often.
  • Experts rank this player at 17th among SS's. Based on his stats from the past 60 days, he is currently ranked 14th.
  • The current leader among SS's is Bobby Witt Jr.
  • He is putting up slightly better numbers than the experts expected him to.
  • Trending Batting Stats

  • Ranked 298th in BABIP (Batting Average on Balls In Play) with 0.265
  • Ranked 277th in batting average with 0.226
  • Not overly impressive with on base percentage currently ranked 214th with 0.322
  • Top 75 in slugging percentage and is currently ranked 61st with 0.492
  • Top 100 in on base plus slugging and is currently ranked 86th with 0.814
  • Top 75 in RBI and is currently ranked 74th with 31
  • Not too impressive and is currently ranked 166th in runs scored with 26
  • Top 35 in HRs and is currently ranked 27th with 14
  • At this point in the season his numbers compared to last years: AVG: +0.222, OBP: +0.316, HRs: +15, RBI: +36, Runs: +28, Wlks: +22, Stls: +1,
Next Up Health Check
Injury Jake McCarthy

No Injury Reported

Injury Colson Montgomery

No Injury Reported

Next Up Matchup Comparison
Matchups Jake McCarthy
DateOpponentResult
Jun 01@LAAAntonio SenzatelaW 8-9
Jun 02@LAATomoyuki SuganoW 2-8
Jun 03@LAAWalbert UrenaL 11-4
Jun 05VS MILBrandon Sproat
Jun 06VS MILJacob Misiorowski
Jun 07VS MILShane Drohan
AVG HR RBI R OBP SLG SB GP
.308123.4000.69203
Season stats based on this weeks opponents
Matchups Colson Montgomery
DateOpponentResult
Jun 01@MINJoe RyanL 9-6
Jun 02@MINConnor PrielippL 6-4
Jun 03@MINErick FeddeW 0-8
Jun 05@PHIJesus Luzardo
Jun 06@PHIAndrew Painter
Jun 07@PHIAaron Nola
AVG HR RBI R OBP SLG SB GP
.214022.2900.28607
Season stats based on this weeks opponents
Next Up Ratings Comparison
Rating Jake McCarthy
9.03
FantasySP Player Rating
Rating Colson Montgomery
11.14
FantasySP Player Rating
Next Up Career Comparison
Career Jake McCarthy
YEAR TM GP H HR R RBI SB BB AVG OBP SLG PTS
2021 ARI 21 12 2 11 4 2 7 .218 .323 .382 47
2022 ARI 81 83 7 47 41 22 21 .296 .353 .443 293
2023 ARI 89 67 2 33 16 26 25 .243 .314 .326 243
2024 ARI 125 126 8 63 56 23 29 .285 .341 .400 418
2025 ARI 65 42 4 18 20 6 10 .204 .243 .345 156
2026 COL 47 43 4 20 25 9 9 .277 .315 .458 157
ON PACE 120 110 10 51 64 23 23 .277 .315 .458 403
3-YEAR AVG 93 78 5 38 31 18 21 .254 .312 .366 272
Career 428 373 27 192 162 88 101 .264 .321 .392
Career Colson Montgomery
YEAR TM GP H HR R RBI SB BB AVG OBP SLG PTS
2025 CHW 71 61 21 43 55 0 25 .239 .312 .529 246
2026 CHW 61 50 15 28 36 1 22 .222 .316 .471 177
ON PACE 159 130 39 73 94 2 57 .222 .316 .471 462
3-YEAR AVG 71 61 21 43 55 0 25 .239 .312 .529 246
Career 132 111 36 71 91 1 47 .231 .314 .502
Think the Start Tool is good? Try this!
  • Optimal Lineups
  • Predictive Analytics Waiver Advice
  • Trade Suggestions & More

Latest from FSP

Player News

Matchups

Week 1
ARI @LAC
ATL @PIT
BAL @IND
BUF @HOU
CAR vs CHI
CIN vs TB
CLE @JAC
DAL @NYG
DEN @KC
DET vs NO
GB @MIN
LAR vs SF
LV vs MIA
NE @SEA
NYJ @TEN
PHI vs WAS
Matchup Time Pitchers
ARI vs LAD 09:40 EDT EST Ryne Nelson
Justin Wrobleski
ATH @CHC 08:05 EDT EST J.T. Ginn
Shota Imanaga
ATL vs TOR 07:15 EDT EST Chris Sale
Mason Fluharty
BAL @BOS 01:35 EDT EST Trevor Rogers
Brayan Bello
CLE @NYY 01:35 EDT EST Slade Cecconi
Carlos Rodon
HOU vs PIT 08:10 EDT EST Kai-Wei Teng
Jared Jones
KC @MIN 07:40 EDT EST Seth Lugo
Andrew Morris
MIL vs SF 02:10 EDT EST Coleman Crow
Adrian Houser
PHI vs SD 01:05 EDT EST Zack Wheeler
Lucas Giolito
Matchup Time
No games scheduled
Matchup Time
VGK @CAR 8:00 PM EST