Dominate Fantasy - Sync your team
MLB
SD
PHI
o8.5
-1.5
1:05PM • PREVIEW NBC
BAL
BOS
o10.5
+1.5
1:35PM • PREVIEW NESN
CLE
NYY
o9
-1.5
1:35PM • PREVIEW YES
SF
MIL
o9
-1.5
2:10PM • PREVIEW BREW
TOR
ATL
o7.5
-1.5
7:15PM • PREVIEW BVSN
KC
MIN
o9
+1.5
7:40PM • PREVIEW MNNT
ATH
CHC
o10
-1.5
8:05PM • PREVIEW NBC
PIT
HOU
o8.5
+1.5
8:10PM • PREVIEW SN LA
LAD
ARI
o9
+1.5
9:40PM • PREVIEW SN LA

Emmet Sheehan or Payton Tolle

Who Should I Start? - Week 12 • Start New
Emmet Sheehan

Emmet Sheehan

SPLos Angeles Dodgers LAD
Payton Tolle

Payton Tolle

SPBoston Red Sox BOS
OR
🔓 EXPERT ANALYSIS

Owners starting Sheehan over Tolle

 
 
 
 
START BOTH START BENCH BOTH BN

Includes Detailed Projections

Outlook Emmet Sheehan

Emmet Sheehan's elite strikeout stuff and a two-start week make him a locked-in fantasy option.

Sheehan has been sharp recently, posting a 3.00 ERA and a 1.00 WHIP with eight strikeouts over his last six innings of work. He is locked in as the number two starter for the first-place Dodgers (38-21), whose rotation depth is currently being tested with Tyler Glasnow and Blake Snell on the injured list.

While his current 4.88 ERA on the year is higher than fantasy managers would like, our model projects him to finish the season with a much stronger 3.86 ERA and a 1.14 WHIP. His elite 10.66 K/9 rate closely mirrors his breakout 2025 campaign, indicating that positive regression to his career baselines is well underway.

Sheehan is a highly valuable two-start pitcher this week, starting on the road against Arizona's Eduardo Rodriguez today before returning home on Sunday to face Jose Soriano and the Angels. Our models project him for 11.1 innings with nearly 11 strikeouts and a clean 1.02 WHIP across these matchups, making him a must-start option.

Updated 3 days ago

Latest News Emmet Sheehan
Loading...
🔓 EXPERT ANALYSIS

Owners starting Tolle over Sheehan

 
 
 
 
START BOTH START BENCH BOTH BN

Includes Detailed Projections

Outlook Payton Tolle

Tolle's high-strikeout upside makes him a strong play as he anchors a depleted Boston rotation

Over the last 30 days, Tolle has been exceptional, posting a 2.98 ERA and a dominant 0.89 WHIP across five starts. The fifth-place Red Sox, sitting at 25-33, have relied heavily on the young southpaw as their rotation anchor with fellow starters Garrett Crochet and Tanner Houck sidelined on the injured list.

Tolle's current 3.12 season ERA and stellar 10.25 K/9 represent a massive leap forward from his brief, rocky 2025 debut. While our models project a minor regression toward a 4.00 ERA and 1.24 WHIP rest-of-season, his elite swing-and-miss stuff makes him a sustainable, high-upside asset in all formats.

Tolle is scheduled for a single start this Wednesday at home against Baltimore, squaring off against Chris Bassitt, who carries a vulnerable 5.06 ERA and 1.58 WHIP. Our models project Tolle to deliver a strong 3.18 ERA and over six strikeouts in this favorable matchup, making him a locked-in option. Verdict: Start.

Updated 3 days ago

Latest News Payton Tolle
Loading...
Performance Emmet Sheehan
Fantasy Chart Loading...

ERA W-L HLD SV SO WLK WHIP GP
2.950-100300.491
Season stats based on the past 7 days

ERA W-L HLD SV SO WLK WHIP GP
2.980-1001110.742
Season stats based on the past 14 days
Performance Payton Tolle
Fantasy Chart Loading...

ERA W-L HLD SV SO WLK WHIP GP
1.761-0001241.572
Season stats based on the past 7 days

ERA W-L HLD SV SO WLK WHIP GP
2.781-0002161.363
Season stats based on the past 14 days
Next Up Own/Start Comparison
OWN/START Emmet Sheehan
OWN
84%
+2.17 compared to last week
START
58%
+8.05 compared to last week
OWN/START Payton Tolle
OWN
82%
-1.49 compared to last week
START
75%
+9.33 compared to last week
Next Up Consensus Rankings
Expert Consensus Emmet Sheehan
41st
Average Ranking of Fantasy Experts
Expert Consensus Payton Tolle
27th
Average Ranking of Fantasy Experts
Next Up Player Breakdowns
Breakdown Emmet Sheehan

    Overview

  • Experts rank this player at 42nd among SP's. Based on his stats from the past 60 days, he is currently ranked 54th.
  • The current leader among SP's is Cristopher Sanchez
  • He should be doing a bit better than this. Look for him to bounce back.
  • Trending Pitching Stats

  • Top 35 in WHIP and is currently ranked 29th with 1.05
  • Top 75 in ERA and is currently ranked 75th with 3.97
  • Top 100 in strikeouts and is currently ranked 97th with 54
  • Currently ranked 156th in wins with 2
  • His average points in the past two weeks have remained fairly consistant and rose slightly by 0.8 PPG.
  • At this point in the season his numbers compared to last years: W: +3, L: +2, WHIP: +1.16, ERA: +4.5, K's: +62, Walks: +14
Breakdown Payton Tolle

    Overview

  • Experts rank this player at 28th among SP's. Based on his stats from the past 60 days, he is currently ranked 41st.
  • The current leader among SP's is Cristopher Sanchez
  • He has been under achieving. Look for him to bounce back.
  • Trending Pitching Stats

  • Top 20 in WHIP and is currently ranked 17th with 1.01
  • Top 25 in ERA and is currently ranked 25th with 2.72
  • Top 100 in wins and is currently ranked 87th
  • His average points in the past two weeks have remained fairly consistant and rose slightly by 0.2 PPG.
  • At this point in the season his numbers compared to last years: W: +3, L: +2, WHIP: +1, ERA: +2.68, K's: +51, Walks: +13
Next Up Health Check
Injury Emmet Sheehan

No Injury Reported

Injury Payton Tolle

No Injury Reported

Next Up Matchup Comparison
Matchups Emmet Sheehan
DateOpponentResult
Jun 01@ARITaylor ClarkeL 4-1
Jun 02@ARIBlake TreinenW 5-6
Jun 03@ARIShohei OhtaniW 0-7
Jun 04@ARIRyne Nelson
Jun 05VS LAAReid Detmers
Jun 06VS LAAJack Kochanowicz
Jun 07VS LAAJose Soriano
ERA W-L HLD SV SO WLK WHIP GP
5.870-100921.092
Season stats based on this weeks opponents
Matchups Payton Tolle
DateOpponentResult
Jun 02VS BALShane BazL 2-4
Jun 03VS BALPayton TolleW 8-1
Jun 04VS BALTrevor Rogers
Jun 05@NYYRyan Weathers
Jun 06@NYYWill Warren
Jun 07@NYYCam Schlittler
ERA W-L HLD SV SO WLK WHIP GP
0.751-0001631.082
Season stats based on this weeks opponents
Next Up Ratings Comparison
Rating Emmet Sheehan
11.07
FantasySP Player Rating
Rating Payton Tolle
11.68
FantasySP Player Rating
Next Up Career Comparison
Career Emmet Sheehan
YEAR TM APP INN PC K WLK SV W-L ERA WHIP K/9 PTS
2023 LAD 14 64.0 1102 68 28 1 4-1 5.06 1.22 9.6 150
2025 LAD 21 78.1 1300 95 27 0 6-3 3.45 1.14 10.9 206
2026 LAD 11 58.0 969 62 14 0 3-2 4.5 1.16 9.6 136
ON PACE 28 152 2531 162 36 0 7-5 4.5 1.16 9.6 354
3-YEAR AVG 12 47 801 54 18 0 3-1 4.1 1.14 10.1 119
Career 46 198.0 3371 225 69 0 0-0 4.32 1.18 10.2
Career Payton Tolle
YEAR TM APP INN PC K WLK SV W-L ERA WHIP K/9 PTS
2025 BOS 8 16.2 311 19 8 0 0-1 5.94 1.56 10.3 23
2026 BOS 8 47.1 688 51 13 0 3-2 2.66 0.99 9.7 128
ON PACE 21 128 1857 137 35 0 8-5 2.66 0.99 9.7 346
3-YEAR AVG 8 16 311 19 8 0 0-1 5.94 1.56 10.3 23
Career 16 64.0 999 70 21 0 0-0 3.52 1.14 9.8
The EDGE you need to WIN!
  • Optimal Lineups
  • Predictive Analytics Waiver Advice
  • Trade Suggestions & More

Latest from FSP

Player News

Matchups

Week 1
ARI @LAC
ATL @PIT
BAL @IND
BUF @HOU
CAR vs CHI
CIN vs TB
CLE @JAC
DAL @NYG
DEN @KC
DET vs NO
GB @MIN
LAR vs SF
LV vs MIA
NE @SEA
NYJ @TEN
PHI vs WAS
Matchup Time Pitchers
ARI vs LAD 09:40 EDT EST Ryne Nelson
Justin Wrobleski
ATH @CHC 08:05 EDT EST J.T. Ginn
Shota Imanaga
ATL vs TOR 07:15 EDT EST Chris Sale
Mason Fluharty
BAL @BOS 01:35 EDT EST Trevor Rogers
Brayan Bello
CLE @NYY 01:35 EDT EST Slade Cecconi
Carlos Rodon
HOU vs PIT 08:10 EDT EST Kai-Wei Teng
Jared Jones
KC @MIN 07:40 EDT EST Seth Lugo
Andrew Morris
MIL vs SF 02:10 EDT EST Coleman Crow
Adrian Houser
PHI vs SD 01:05 EDT EST Zack Wheeler
Lucas Giolito
Matchup Time
No games scheduled
Matchup Time
VGK @CAR 8:00 PM EST