Fantasy Hockey Injury Report: Avalanche Keep Winning Without MacKinnon and Makar, and More
Shelmo discusses a pair of devastating injuries to Colorado's biggest stars, another setback for a key Montreal defensemen and a long-awaited season debut for an Islanders forward.
Hey folks. We're already a quarter of the way through the NHL season, and injuries are beginning to have a significant impact on fantasy hockey rosters. The Colorado Avalanche took a major hit when two of their biggest stars went down in the same game, but somehow this team continues to find ways to win.
Montreal has another frustrating injury situation on its hands, with a key defenseman struggling to stay healthy and missing more time after just returning to the lineup. Meanwhile, there is finally some good news coming out of Long Island, as a familiar face makes his long-awaited season debut and immediately gets on the scoresheet.
With fantasy managers having to navigate injuries, lineup changes and opportunities for replacement players, there is plenty to discuss as we head toward the second quarter of the season. Let's dive in.
Want to take your fantasy hockey analysis further? EDGE+ members can now chat with our AI Expert, ask follow-up questions, and dive deeper into player breakdowns with longer conversations.
Nathan MacKinnon – Colorado Avalanche
The Colorado Avalanche have suffered a massive blow, losing two of their biggest stars in the same game, and unfortunately for fantasy managers, Nate Mac is expected to miss at least one month with a lower-body injury. MacKinnon was injured Thursday against Ottawa after attempting a reverse hit on Senators defenseman Artem Zub, grabbing at his right side before eventually leaving the game.
Head coach Jared Bednar confirmed the timeline Saturday, and while there is always hope that a player can return ahead of schedule, fantasy managers should prepare to be without one of the league's best forwards for a significant stretch.
Connect your league to uncover strengths & weaknesses, waiver assistance, trade scenarios, and get instant start/sit clarity.
MacKinnon has been outstanding once again this season, recording 30 points through 20 games while continuing to pile up goals and shots on net. He is normally the king of fantasy hockey, but Connor McDavid's historic start has pushed him into the second spot among fantasy forwards this season. That certainly doesn't make MacKinnon any less valuable, however, as he remains an elite fantasy asset and an unquestionable keeper in every format.
Losing him for a month is going to hurt, especially for managers who spent a first-round pick to acquire him, but this is absolutely not a situation where you should be looking to sell low.
The good news for Colorado is that the team managed to respond immediately, picking up a 4-1 victory over the Habs in its first game without their two biggest stars - more on that next.
That is an impressive result, but replacing MacKinnon's offensive production over the next month is going to take a collective effort. Nazem Kadri and Brock Nelson are the obvious candidates to benefit from increased responsibilities, with Nelson already finding the back of the net against Montreal.
Fantasy outlook: MacKinnon is an automatic hold in every format, and there is no reason to panic just because he is expected to miss a month. This is one of the best players in fantasy hockey, and his production will be difficult to replace, even if McDavid has taken over the top spot this season.
Keep him in your IR spot if available, be patient with the recovery, and look for short-term replacements rather than making a desperate trade. MacKinnon will be right back among the elite fantasy options when he returns.
Cale Makar – Colorado Avalanche
Well, it looks like the Edmonton Oilers are taking over fantasy hockey, and Makar is the latest superstar to find himself dethroned. Much like MacKinnon has been pushed down the rankings by McDavid, Makar is now looking up at another Oilers star in Evan Bouchard.
Seriously, what is happening in Edmonton? Has Mike Babcock unlocked a bunch of Super Saiyans, or are we just witnessing an unbelievable run from the Oilers' biggest fantasy assets?
Either way, Bouchard has been outstanding, but don't mistake Makar's current ranking for a decline in his fantasy value.
Unfortunately, Makar is joining MacKinnon on the injury list after suffering a lower-body injury against Ottawa on Thursday. Head coach Jared Bednar indicated that Makar will miss approximately two weeks, putting an early December return in the picture.
The injury is believed to be a soft-tissue issue that had been bothering him before it worsened against the Senators. Makar has five goals and 23 points through 19 games, and losing him for even a couple of weeks is a significant blow to Colorado's offense.
The good news is, like we mentioned earlier, that Colorado did manage to beat the Habs without either MacKinnon or Makar. That's encouraging, but I wouldn't expect the Avalanche to maintain quite the same level of offensive production or win percentage without their dynamic duo.
There is simply too much talent missing from this lineup, and the remaining players will need to shoulder considerably more responsibility.
Fantasy outlook: Makar is a top defenseman in fantasy hockey and an automatic hold in every format. There is no reason to panic over a short-term injury, and managers should be looking to keep him tucked away in their IR spots until he is ready to return.
Bouchard might be enjoying his time at the top of the fantasy defensemen rankings, but Makar isn't going anywhere. Expect some offensive regression from Colorado while both superstars are out, but this is still one of the best teams in the league, and Makar will be right back among the elite once healthy.
Mike Matheson – Montreal Canadiens
There is something concerning happening with Matheson, who just can't seem to stay in the lineup. After missing six games with a lower-body injury, Matheson returned against Boston on November 12, picked up an assist and logged over 21 minutes, only to miss the next game against Colorado. He has now been ruled out of Montreal's upcoming three-game road trip, despite previously being upgraded to day-to-day.
Matheson has appeared in just nine games this season, but remains a valuable fantasy contributor when healthy, averaging over 23 minutes per game and providing excellent peripheral production. Unfortunately, none of that helps fantasy managers when he's spending more time watching from the press box than playing.
Fantasy outlook: Continue to monitor Matheson's status, but this situation is getting concerning. He's worth holding in deeper formats because of his minutes and peripherals, but managers in shallower leagues may need to consider other options if these absences continue. He's simply not providing enough offensive production to justify sitting in your lineup when he isn't playing.
Mathew Barzal – New York Islanders
One of my favorite underrated fantasy contributors is finally back! Barzal made his season debut Saturday against Anaheim after missing the first 18 games with left knee inflammation, and wasted no time getting on the scoresheet with an assist in the Islanders' 6-2 victory. He played 16:21 and registered four shots, which is an encouraging start after such a lengthy absence.
Barzal is an important piece of this Islanders offense and should work his way into a top-six role alongside a spot on the first powerplay unit as he gets back up to speed. He has always been a sneaky source of fantasy production, and I think managers sometimes overlook just how valuable he can be when healthy.
Fantasy outlook: Expect immediate production from this elite forward as he gets comfortable again. If you've been holding Barzal on IR all season, your patience is finally about to pay off. Get him back into your lineup and enjoy having this underrated fantasy contributor back!