Dominate Fantasy - Sync your team
MLB
MIL
PIT
7
5
FINALFINAL
PHI
CIN
5
0
FINALFINAL
BOS
CLE
4
6
FINALFINAL
CHW
MIN
3
6
FINALFINAL
TOR
KC
1
2
FINALFINAL
HOU
CHC
1
3
FINALFINAL
SEA
TEX
4
3
FINALFINAL
SD
COL
9
10
FINALFINAL
LAD
WSH
2
1
FINALFINAL
OAK
NYY
3
1
TOP 5 T5 • VIEW MATCHUP LIVE

Thairo Estrada or Josh Naylor

Who Should I Start? - Week 5 • Start New
Thairo Estrada

Thairo Estrada

2BSan Francisco Giants SF
Josh Naylor

Josh Naylor

1BCleveland Guardians CLE
OR
🔓 EXPERT ANALYSIS

Owners starting Estrada over Naylor

 
 
 
 
START BOTH START BENCH BOTH BN

Includes Detailed Projections

Latest News Thairo Estrada
Loading...
🔓 EXPERT ANALYSIS

Owners starting Naylor over Estrada

 
 
 
 
START BOTH START BENCH BOTH BN

Includes Detailed Projections

Latest News Josh Naylor
Loading...
Performance Thairo Estrada
Fantasy Chart Loading...

AVG HR RBI R OBP SLG SB GP
.208023.2400.33307
Season stats based on the past 7 days

AVG HR RBI R OBP SLG SB GP
.311268.3400.578013
Season stats based on the past 14 days
Performance Josh Naylor
Fantasy Chart Loading...

AVG HR RBI R OBP SLG SB GP
.250282.2500.54206
Season stats based on the past 7 days

AVG HR RBI R OBP SLG SB GP
.2833115.3270.522012
Season stats based on the past 14 days
Next Up Own/Start Comparison
OWN/START Thairo Estrada
OWN
62%
-2.98 compared to last week
START
39%
-18.61 compared to last week
OWN/START Josh Naylor
OWN
100%
No change since last week.
START
95%
+0.26 compared to last week
Next Up Consensus Rankings
Expert Consensus Thairo Estrada
17th
Average Ranking of Fantasy Experts
Expert Consensus Josh Naylor
7th
Average Ranking of Fantasy Experts
Next Up Player Breakdowns
Breakdown Thairo Estrada

    Overview

  • Experts rank this player at 17th among 2B's. Based on his stats from the past 60 days, he is currently ranked 14th.
  • The current leader among 2B's is Ketel Marte
  • He is putting up slightly better numbers than the experts expected him to.
  • He hasn't missed that many games lately, but he is listed on the injury report. He may have some nagging injuries with his Hamstring (Since Apr 24, 2024). Look at his player news.
  • Trending Batting Stats

  • Ranked 214th in BABIP (Batting Average on Balls In Play) with 0.304
  • Ranked 179th in batting average with 0.257
  • Not overly impressive with on base percentage currently ranked 384th with 0.283
  • Not too impressive with slugging percentage currently ranked 255th with 0.393
  • Not too impressive with on base plus slugging currently ranked 304th with 0.677
  • Not very impressive in steals and is currently ranked 449th with 5
  • Not too impressive and is currently ranked 274th in RBI with 30
  • Not too impressive and is currently ranked 320th in runs scored with 28
  • His average points in the past two weeks have remained fairly consistant and rose slightly by 0.2 PPG.
  • At this point in the season his numbers compared to last years: AVG: -0.039, OBP: -0.062, HRs: -11, RBI: -37, Runs: -52, Wlks: -19, Stls: -23,
  • The season is still young, expect things to change quite a bit.
Breakdown Josh Naylor

    Overview

  • Experts rank this player at 8th among 1B's. Based on his stats from the past 60 days, he is currently ranked 1st.
  • The current leader among 1B's is Josh Naylor
  • He is putting up better numbers than the experts expected him to.
  • Trending Batting Stats

  • Ranked 160th in BABIP (Batting Average on Balls In Play) with 0.315
  • Top 10 in batting average with 0.318 and is currently ranked 10th
  • Top 35 on base percentage and is currently ranked 28th with 0.377
  • Top 35 in slugging percentage and is currently ranked 35th with 0.536
  • Top 35 in on base plus slugging and is currently ranked 28th with 0.913
  • Not very impressive in steals and is currently ranked 180th with 5
  • Top 75 in RBI and is currently ranked 56th with 57
  • Not too impressive and is currently ranked 241st in runs scored with 34
  • At this point in the season his numbers compared to last years: AVG: -0.004, OBP: +0.015, HRs: -11, RBI: -77, Runs: -39, Wlks: -25, Stls: -10,
Next Up Health Check
Injury Thairo Estrada

HAMSTRING - Since Apr 24, 2024

Estrada is dealing with left hamstring tightness and is uncertain to take the field for the Giants.
Injury Josh Naylor

No Injury Reported

Next Up Matchup Comparison
Matchups Thairo Estrada
DateOpponentResult
Apr 22VS NYMKeaton WinnW 5-2
Apr 23VS NYMLogan WebbW 5-1
Apr 24VS NYMReed GarrettL 2-8
Apr 26VS PITQuinn Priester
Apr 27VS PITMartin Perez
Apr 28VS PITJared Jones
AVG HR RBI R OBP SLG SB GP
.250012.3330.50003
Season stats based on this weeks opponents
Matchups Josh Naylor
DateOpponentResult
Apr 23VS BOSScott BarlowW 4-1
Apr 24VS BOSCooper CriswellL 0-8
Apr 25VS BOSChase Anderson
Apr 26@ATLChris Sale
Apr 27@ATLCharlie Morton
Apr 28@ATLBryce Elder
AVG HR RBI R OBP SLG SB GP
.208011.2080.20806
Season stats based on this weeks opponents
Next Up Ratings Comparison
Rating Thairo Estrada
14.80
FantasySP Player Rating
Rating Josh Naylor
18.24
FantasySP Player Rating
Next Up Career Comparison
Career Thairo Estrada
YEAR TM GP H HR R RBI SB BB AVG OBP SLG PTS
2019 NYY 34 16 3 12 12 4 3 .250 .294 .438 56
2020 NYY 27 7 1 9 4 1 1 .149 .231 .213 16
2021 SF 51 30 5 17 19 1 9 .259 .323 .422 124
2022 SF 133 117 14 69 58 18 32 .255 .318 .402 426
2023 SF 122 134 14 63 49 23 22 .271 .315 .416 388
2024 SF 26 22 3 11 12 0 3 .232 .253 .400 66
ON PACE 162 137 18 68 74 0 18 .232 .253 .400 411
3-YEAR AVG 102 94 11 50 42 14 21 .263 .317 .411 313
Career 393 326 40 181 154 47 70 .256 .308 .404
Career Josh Naylor
YEAR TM GP H HR R RBI SB BB AVG OBP SLG PTS
2019 SD 94 63 8 29 32 1 25 .249 .315 .403 158
2020 SD 42 29 2 16 9 1 5 .279 .318 .413 69
2021 CLE 70 59 7 28 21 1 14 .258 .306 .406 184
2022 CLE 128 114 21 47 77 5 33 .260 .316 .463 422
2023 CLE 128 140 17 52 97 10 33 .310 .356 .491 484
2024 CLE 23 26 6 13 20 0 8 .306 .371 .576 102
ON PACE 155 175 40 87 135 0 54 .306 .371 .576 688
3-YEAR AVG 109 104 15 42 65 5 27 .280 .330 .463 363
Career 485 431 61 185 256 18 118 .276 .329 .456
Think the Start Tool is good? Try this!
  • Optimal Lineups
  • Predictive Analytics Waiver Advice
  • Trade Suggestions & More

RECENT DECISIONS

Player News

Matchups

Week 22
KC vs SF
SF vs KC
Matchup Time Pitchers
BOS @CLE 01:10 EDT EST Chase Anderson
Triston McKenzie
CHC vs HOU 02:20 EDT EST Javier Assad
Justin Verlander
CHW @MIN 01:10 EDT EST Michael Soroka
Simeon Woods Richardson
CIN vs PHI 01:10 EDT EST Nick Martinez
Zack Wheeler
COL vs SD 03:10 EDT EST Dakota Hudson
Randy Vasquez
KC vs TOR 02:10 EDT EST Cole Ragans
Jose Berrios
LAD @WAS 04:05 EDT EST Yoshinobu Yamamoto
MacKenzie Gore
MIL @PIT 12:35 EDT EST Freddy Peralta
Mitch Keller
NYY vs OAK 07:05 EDT EST Nestor Cortes
Alex Wood
SEA @TEX 02:35 EDT EST Luis Castillo
Andrew Heaney
Matchup Time
CLE @ORL 7:00 PM EST
DEN @LAL 10:00 PM EST
NY @PHI 7:30 PM EST
Matchup Time
CAR @NYI 7:30 PM EST
FLA @TB 7:00 PM EST